VIDEO: BMW 840d vs BMW M140i vs BMW E60 M5

1 Series, 8 Series, BMW M5, Videos | April 27th, 2019 by 3
Screenshot 269 830x553

The performance of even pretty ordinary cars has come a long, long way in just the past few years. So much in fact that even …

The performance of even pretty ordinary cars has come a long, long way in just the past few years. So much in fact that even cars that are only a bit warm have what it takes to take on fully hot performance machines from not too long ago and actually keep up. We get to see that in this video from Carwow, where an E60 BMW M5 drag races a new BMW M140i and the brand-new BMW 840d.

Typically, these three cars would never even be considered to be competitors in any way. The E60 M5 is a proper BMW M product that packs a motorsport-inspired naturally-aspirated V10. While the M140i is an M Performance hot hatch and not a proper M car. Lastly, the BMW 840d isn’t even an M-lite but just a regular ole diesel coupe.

E60 BMW M5 30 830x553

On paper, the E60 M5 should smoke the other two. With 500 hp from its 5.0 liter V10, it out-muscles the M140i’s 335 hp from its 3.0 liter turbocharged I6 and the 316 hp from the BMW 840d’s 3.0 liter turbo I6 diesel. And, honestly, the old M5 does win every race. However, the races are closer than you’d might expect.

In the first standing drag race, the E60 M5 smokes its rear tires to pieces, giving it a bad start. But it must be said that the M5 is not an easy car to launch well so its bad start is actually much of its own fault. With that bad start, the other two cars jump ahead immediately, especially the grippy all-wheel drive 8er. However, once the M5 reigns its power and traction in, it takes off and simply walks ahead of, and away from, the other two. After that, they do a rolling drag race and the E60 M5 wins again.

BMW 840d xDrive Mineral White 25 830x553

They also do a braking test, which didn’t have a clear winner, as the E60 M5 and the BMW 840d were so close it was too hard to tell them apart. But they both beat the litter 1er.

So yes, the proper M car, the high-performance thoroughbred, won basically everything. However, the other two cars did better than expect and got closer than many of enthusiasts might have anticipated. It just goes to show how far modern performance machines have gotten.

3 responses to “VIDEO: BMW 840d vs BMW M140i vs BMW E60 M5”

  1. Dougefresh says:

    I’m happy to see the video mentioned torque. Because that is the huge different in diesel vs gas. But if you’re going to write an article comparing them, you have to mention HP, torque, and weight. Especially in a drag race.

    • manuelf says:

      Moreover: Engine torque is completely irrelevant here! Torque at wheel is the important thing. This makes good dragstrip performance and there you have to take gearing into account, which tells you how engine torque is transformed to torque at wheels at how long it can be sustained…

  2. Andrewthecarguy says:

    Interesting video. It is good to see a true M product, 2 generations removed, still perform in a manner that other 2 couldn’t. That said, I think each car brings something different to the table and were excellent in each case,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.