A few days ago, I was getting gas and went into the store to get a coffee and, on my way out, saw a BMW Z4 M40i parked off to the side. Seeing one in the wild felt foreign, as I realized that I’d never actually seen one on the road before. The only Z4s I’d ever seen prior to that day were BMW’s press cars, either ones I was testing or ones off to the side at press events. That realization made me sad because the BMW Z4 M40i is a really good car but one that’s completely under appreciated.

The Z4 M40i isn’t a perfect car, nor is even the best convertible sports car for the money. That’s why it doesn’t sell. For the same money, you can get a base Porsche Boxster and, for not much more money, you can have a C8 Corvette Convertible. For less money, you can have a Mustang GT Convertible with a V8 a more seats. So the Z4 M40i doesn’t really seem like great value. However, there’s still a reason to get the Z4 M40i and I feel like more people should still be buying it.

BMW Z4 M40i First Edition Czech market launch 20 830x553

For starters, it’s seriously fast. The 3.0 liter turbocharged I6 in the M40i version is a thing of joy. It makes 382 horsepower and 369 lb-ft of torque and delivers all of it with a massive punch in the back. The cute little bug-eyes looks completely belie the monster performance that lies underneath. A Mustang GT Convertible might have a much bigger engine with more power but the Z4 M40i will give one a real fright on the road.

It’s also really fun to drive. Of course, it’s not a scalpel, like the Porsche Boxster is, but it has this really nice blend of sports car and muscle car. Because of that big engine underneath that long hood and its rear-drive nature, it feels a bit like a muscle car. However, because it sits so low to the ground and, as the driver, it feels like you’re sitting on the rear axle, it has a very bespoke sports car feel. It’s actually quite a unique driving experience in this current era of sports cars.

BMW Z4 M40i First Edition Czech market launch 33 830x553

Also, it’s a proper roadster. The classic roadster recipe is to have a big engine up front, driver in the middle, no back seats, and rear-wheel drive. Very few cars in the Z4’s price point offer such a package, which makes it different and special.

Would I buy a Z4 M40i over a Boxster? No, probably not (mostly because the Boxster is mid-engine and comes with a manual, which is my perfect sports car recipe). However, I’d absolutely consider it and I think more people should. I think if more customers actually considered the Z4 M40i, and really gave it a shot, more people would buy it.