New Porsche Cayman GT4 could take on the BMW M4

Interesting, Others | February 4th, 2015 by 12
2015 porsche cayman gt4 images 01 750x500

Meet the Porsche Cayman GT4. Would the BMW M4 have a punchers chance?

BMW, and their famous M3, have always ruled the sports car world. The M3 (and now M4 as well) have dominated cars within its price range since its inception. Nothing else was able to combine the handling chops, driving purity, fun and comfort that the M3 had. However, when Porsche released the Cayman in 2006, they stuck a big thorn in BMW’s side. Not only was the Cayman the best sports car in the segment, it was one of the best sports cars in the world. The new Cayman was released in 2013 and was almost immediately declared the best sports car in the world.

Unfortunately for BMW, Porsche has just made the spectacular Cayman even better.

Meet the Cayman GT4.

2015 porsche cayman gt4 images 07 750x458

The Cayman S makes 325 hp from its 3.4 liter, flat-six and can hit 60 mph in 4.7 seconds, as claimed by Porsche (even though Car and Driver did the deed in 4.2). The new GT4 has a revised version of the 911’s 3.8 liter, flat-six, making 385 hp and can hit 60 mph from a standstill in a claimed 4.2 seconds (which is probably wildly underestimated). That isn’t the big news, however. The big news is that (purists rejoice!) it will come exclusively with a 6-speed manual. No PDK, 7-speed, twin-clutch auto available in the GT4. This comes as a major relief to those who saw the loss of the 911 GT3’s manual as a sign of Porsche going soft.

2015 porsche cayman gt4 images 05 750x458

Other big news is the GT4’s suspension bits. Made with mostly 911 GT3 parts, the suspension is full-on track ready. The GT4 will also come with dynamic transmission mounts, and a 1.2” lower ride height. It also looks the part of a GT3 with its aggressive aero dynamics and huge rear-wing. Carbon ceramic brakes will also be available, to help the GT4 stop as well as it goes and handles.

2015-porsche-cayman-gt4-images-10

All of this go-fast tech will make an already impressive handling car even more so. The standard Cayman was a formidable thing on both road and track, and could scare the pants off any sports car that dared to face it. This GT4 will make other sports cars run and hide. It should scare them even further considering the GT4 checks in at $85,595. That’s around $50,000 less than its 911 GT3 older brother.

2015-porsche-cayman-gt4-images-03

Does BMW have anything that can compete? At the moment, the only car that BMW has to throw at the GT4 would be the M4, but I feel that’s an unfair fight. The M4 could take on the Cayman S, as both are similarly priced and have similar performance numbers. But the Cayman GT4 is a track-focused, hardcore sports car primed and ready to eat some of the best cars in the world for lunch. Would the M4 have a punchers chance?

If BMW comes out with a competition pack, it would. At the moment, the M4 doesn’t have its own ultra-performance variant, like the GT4 is to the Cayman. Some kind of competition pack, offering sportier suspension and brakes, a bump in power and some more aggressive aero bits, would put the M4 right into the conversation. Maybe take out the rear seats and offer carbon-shelled racing seats as well. All of this would lighten and tighten the M4 up and unlock some of its performance potential. There’s no doubt the M4 has the firepower to keep up in a drag race, in fact the M4 is faster in a straight line. With 425 hp, the M4 sprints to 60 mph in 3.7 seconds, which should leave the GT4 for dead. Now imagine an M4 GTS in the near future.

However, once the road gets twisty, the GT4 could put a hurting on the M4. Not that the M4 is a bad handling car, in fact it’s quite fantastic, but the lighter, mid-engined GT4 is has an advantage in balance and grip. And with its lighter front-end, thanks to the mid-engine layout, it should produce a sharper turn-in. It definitely would be an interesting matchup, especially if the M4 gets some kind of competition pack. Could the raw power of the M4 be enough to top the quick-hitting GT4? I’m not sure, but I can’t wait to find out.

Let the Battle of The 4s begin.

12 responses to “New Porsche Cayman GT4 could take on the BMW M4”

  1. jason bourne says:

    Two different automobile classes… The M4 is a sports coupe and the GT4 is a sports car.

    You don’t see a Porsche racing in DTM, huh?

  2. jason bourne says:

    Two different automobile classes… The M4 is a sports coupe and the GT4 is a sports car.

    You don’t see a Porsche racing in DTM, huh?

  3. jti107 says:

    probably kill a m4 but it still looks like every other porsche…if looks dont matter…get a used gtr

  4. planetnine says:

    I have news for you, my 2006 987 Cayman S routinely trounces both M3’s and M4’s at the track, the new Cayman GT4 will continue that tradition with ease. M3 and M4 aren’t competition for the Cayman, they are big fat heavy sedans with gobs of power. BMW needs to make something lightweight that handles well. I teach at BMW driving schools and I let students take my Cayman out and they are in awe of the handling differences between the cars.

    • m42b18 says:

      The difference is that the BMW is a more livable car. You can get groceries, go golfing, take 3 or more people, etc.

      That said, with enough money to relegate your gt4 to weekend status, it makes the porsche very tempting. 385 hp is excellent in such a light car.

    • m42b18 says:

      The difference is that the BMW is a more livable car. You can get groceries, go golfing, take 3 or more people, etc.

      That said, with enough money to relegate your gt4 to weekend status, it makes the porsche very tempting. 385 hp is excellent in such a light car.

      • planetnine says:

        While I agree that the BMW is going to be more livable than the Cayman with its backseat and ability to carry more passengers I would counter argue that I’ve used my 2006 Cayman S as a daily driver for almost 10 years and it has been driven from coast to coast and long trips multiple times. I use it to get groceries (It has 2 trunks) and unless I need to haul the kids somewhere at the same time it is a great date night car. :) The Cayman is certainly one of the most livable 2 seat sports cars on the market, it doesn’t beat you up like the GT3, and has more creature comforts than a Lotus. But as someone said the BMW vs Cayman is really comparing a sports sedan vs. a sports car. Get one of each if you can swing it!

  5. planetnine says:

    I have news for you, my 2006 987 Cayman S routinely trounces both M3’s and M4’s at the track, the new Cayman GT4 will continue that tradition with ease. M3 and M4 aren’t competition for the Cayman, they are big fat heavy sedans with gobs of power. BMW needs to make something lightweight that handles well. I teach at BMW driving schools and I let students take my Cayman out and they are in awe of the handling differences between the cars.

  6. roginator says:

    Sadly it feels like the M4 is more muscle car than light weight GT. The original E30 M3 and E36 M3 were relatively light and had good but not crazy power. The downwards trend started with the E46 M cars.

    They went from truly track focused sedans to everyman muscle cars.

  7. Nohj says:

    You made this article because you really wanted to say “Let the battle of the 4’s begin”, didn’t you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

NEWSLETTER