To Buy or Not to Buy? Winter Tires are the Question

Car Tips, Featured Posts | February 5th, 2010 by 25
Yokohama IG 20 750x500 To Buy or Not to Buy? Winter Tires are the Question

Here is the answer. The time is around 19:00 hours on a cold, blustery winter night. The temperature is hovering around -1 and it has …

snow covered road To Buy or Not to Buy? Winter Tires are the Question

Here is the answer.

The time is around 19:00 hours on a cold, blustery winter night. The temperature is hovering around -1 and it has been raining, a dangerous stage for icy conditions. Having left the shop with 4 new winter tires installed only that morning, what I encountered next had me kissing all four corners of my contact patch.

Traveling South bound on Windsor’s Huron Church Ave, one of North America’s busiest roads with high truck traffic, I came upon an intersection where the two right lanes of the 3 Southbound lanes were at a stand still, tens of semi trucks lumbering through first gear. With a fresh green displayed, I approach the intersection just below the speed limit, a clear lane lies ahead. With no warning or signal, a flat-bed semi-truck makes a sudden move pulling into my lane from stand-still (trucks are altogether banned from this “fast” lane on Huron Church, I guess he’s a new, careless, or drunk driver).

Hard on the brakes with a tall concrete barrier to the left and a nose-to-tail barrier of trucks to the right, I have nowhere to go. Visions of my seemingly imminent decapitation loom close, the flat bed trailer lying like opened scissors across the road ahead, at approximately the height of my dash. Feathering the brakes I play with the limit of tire adhesion to the road, attempting to burn off velocity as if my life depended on it, because, my life depended on it. As I closed in on the last few feet of remaining asphalt, I was amazed to bring the car to a complete stop. The truck driver who cut off my lane had his truck at a full stop, realizing his trailer did not have enough space to complete the lane change without side swiping the truck in front. Both of us at a stand still, my hood about 2 feet from the sharp metal edge of his trailer, a moment of clarity dawned. I literally owed my life to the tires I had just purchased – because any less traction on that slippery, freezing night would have resulted in my obituary and a very small inheritance debt passed on to my beneficiaries.

330i drift through snow 655x193 To Buy or Not to Buy? Winter Tires are the Question

It’s not just about snow and ice.

Most people believe in the misnomer that winter tires are needed for snow and ice, but since they live in a part of the Country where there is little precipitation and only cold temperatures, they would not benefit from winter tires. This is a fallacy. The chemistry of winter tires has been perfected to suit the unique driving environment of winter roads. When all-season or summer performance tires start to lose grip, hardening under cold temperatures – winter tires are just coming into their peak operating temperature range, soft and pliable, ready to grip the asphalt. The transition temperature where summer performance tires or all-season tires lose traction and winter tires enter their peak operating window is around 7′ Celsius (44.6 degrees Fahrenheit).

We could break the science of winter tires into two categories: mechanical grip and molecular adhesion.

Mechanical grip refers to the physical mating of the tread to the road surface. The malleability of the rubber compound allows it to “interlock” with the undulations of the road surface (the rough rock/sand/tar or concrete surface). Once again, temperature affects the malleability of the rubber compound, so pliable rubber compounds allow better traction. The tread pattern’s ability to evacuate slush or water is also essential to mating the tread to the road surface. Adding another facet to the tread pattern, winter tires contain thousands of tire “sipes” that act as separate biting edges in the snow. These sipes also add flexibility to the tread surface, which in turn, adds more grip on ice and snow. One interesting technology in particular has negated any need for studded tires (winter tires with small metal spikes screwed into the surface); this technology gains traction at a microscopic level using millions of “bite particles” to spike into the ice or snow.

studded tire

Toyo, for instance, utilize walnut shells to add traction on ice. Walnut shells are first pulverized into a fine powder and then mixed into the tread compound. At a microscopic scale each individual particle represents a sharp shard of broken shell, ready to act as an ice pick sticking out of the tire. As the tire wears, fresh shards of walnut shell surface, providing additional grip. When you consider that studded tires may have around 10 spikes in contact with the road surface at any given time, while modern winter tires have thousands of individual bite particles in contact at with the road surface at any moment – the advantage of microscopic “bite particle” technology becomes clear. Other manufacturers use different bite particle materials while operating on the same design premise. Lastly, modern winter tires contain “micro cells” or “tubules” that literally suck water off the surface of the ice or snow they’re rolling over to allow better contact between the tread and the surface beneath (consider that as ice or snow is compressed at temperatures near the melting point they release water to the surface, which effectively produces ‘micro-aquaplaning’ and reduces traction).

Secondly, we have molecular adhesion between the rubber and the road surface. At an atomic level, bonding takes place between the road surface and the tire compound as they meet. Depending on the condition of the road surface (dry vs wet), the chemistry of the rubber compound will dictate how much adhesion is available via molecular bonding. For instance, Silica is added to winter tires as it has an affinity to water molecules, and thus offers greater wet traction by bonding to the wet surface.

e36 winter rally

While these technologies may seem impressive on paper, they are staggering in practice. The traction available from the best winter tires can sometimes mimic the traction available from all-seasons on wet pavement while your driving on snow. I will even admit to driving snow covered logging trails with a 2 wheel drive car wearing Toyo winter tires… and making it out without a tow or a winch.

They say that “a chain is only as strong as its weakest link.” On snow covered roads, your tires are invariably the weakest link – unless they are quality winter tires. Earlier in the article, we briefly mentioned the relevance of all wheel drive in winter driving. Without question, AWD does offer additional traction for acceleration on slippery surfaces. However, AWD does not increase the tire’s traction with the road surface, it simply makes better use of available traction by distributing power more effectively to the road. Since maximal tire grip is finite, you cannot expect a tire to effectively turn a vehicle and accelerate concurrently without compromise (understeer). Therefore, AWD does not offer a large advantage with additional cornering speed on slippery surfaces, nor can it stop a vehicle faster. The benefit of AWD is limited on slippery surfaces, and ultimately, winter tires will go much further to assist you in winter driving than AWD ever could.

330i drift through snow driver training

A matter of money.

While most motorists sliding out of control will tell you that winter tires are too expensive for them to justify, I believe in a simple truth that completely contradicts this claim. Winter tires are cheaper than insurance hikes and bodywork. And you can’t put a price on your safety. Most quality winter tires will offer a tread-life of three to four years before replacement is necessary, so divide the purchase cost over three to four years when you budget for them. Since you never drive your winter tires through the summer you can effectively cut down on their wear and this allows you to enjoy both winter traction, and an entertaining, fun-filled summer with a set a performance summer tires.

A common absurdity is the notion that somehow a really talented driver can drive through snow without winter tires. Well yes, it’s true – I have even driven a shopping cart through snow. This does not reflect on driver talent, but rather shows a lack of understanding. It is even possible to drive through snow with summer performance tires, but this simply displays a wonton lack of respect for the physics at play, your personal safety and a gross disregard for others on the road.

The truth is out.

All seasons are like a pair of walking shoes. You can take a nice easy walk in them, and they’ll perform okay. You could run in them, you could hike in them, you could play basket ball or tennis in them, you could golf in them, you could mountain climb in them, but they do not accomplish any of the preceding tasks very well. They are truly a “Jack of all trades, master of none.” By definition, all-season tires are a compromise: why compromise your safety and driving pleasure?

M3 spins in snow

Winter tires offer so much available traction and driving enjoyment that I regularly make it a point to go out and drive after a heavy snowfall, or better yet, in the middle of a snowstorm. The proper equipment can render an inhospitable environment as a playground for your exploration and enjoyment.

Slipin and Slide’in or Drifting and Gliding? The choice is up to you.

Editors Picks:

While there are a multitude of excellent winter tires from various brands including Hakkapeliitta and Pirelli, I will focus in on the tires I have personally found to offer the best performance.

Toyo Observe G-02 Plus

-How do you compliment the tire that saved your life? Superlative deep snow and ice traction at the sacrifice of dry road handling. This tire has marked “tire squirm” but compensates with phenomenal traction when the winter gets rough. Tread wear is average, lasting 3 seasons of spirited driving (conservative driving on dry roads for the most part, so as to preserve them).

Yokohama IG 20 IceGaurds

Yokohama IG-20

-Your ‘Best Value’ high quality winter tire. While it may ring in the least expensive of this group, do not dismiss its performance abilities. Worn as the tire choice in Ontario’s winter rally racing, this tire needs no introduction. Excellent snow and good ice traction round out this race-winning tire. Dry handling is compromised, but not as much as many others including the Toyo Observe G-02 Plus. Tire life is slightly better than average in its class.

Bridgestone Blizzak WS60

Bridgestone Blizzak WS60 Tire Bridgestone Blizzak WS60 Tire

Bridgestone Blizzak WS60 Tire priced from $68.

-Often acclaimed as the world’s best winter tire, the Blizzak sets the bar high. Now in its third generation, it has been recently redesigned for ever-better drive characteristics and traction; the Blizzak doesn’t disappoint. Probably one of the best all-round winter tires with excellent snow and ice traction, a relatively quiet ride, and better than average dry road handling in its class. You will not regret this purchase. Tire life is better than average, easily lasting 3 years of spirited winter driving (with more conservative driving on dry roads so as to preserve the tread).

For uncompromising dry road traction with high speed capability and performance as well as good grip on snow and ice, I would recommend the following:

Michelin Alpin PA3

Michelin Pilot Alpin PA3 Tire Michelin Pilot Alpin PA3 Tire

Michelin Pilot Alpin PA3 Tire priced from $119.

-Enjoyed best on the M3, this tire makes you forget you switched to your winters. Excellent dry road handling and traction with no noticeable tire squirm. When things get slippery, the Michelin keeps up, though snow and ice traction is compromised in exchange for its dry road performance. Tire life is excellent, one of the best in class.

Bridgestone Blizzak LM-25

Bridgestone Blizzak LM-25 Tire

Bridgestone Blizzak LM-25 Tire

Bridgestone Blizzak LM-25 Tire priced from $105.

-This performance winter tire will have you questioning the relevance of many other winter tires. Currently on my BMW, these tires have displayed superior dry road handling while not trading off too much compact or deep snow traction. Traction on ice is noticeably less than its purist snow tire-brother, the WS60. However the LM-25 rewards you with dry road handling approaching the levels of a summer performance tire. Best of all, its unique rubber compound with “Long Link Carbon” renders it one of the longest lasting winter tires available in its class. Traction through slush is phenomenal, one of the best slush tires I’ve ever driven. With spirited dry-road driving, the LM-25 will last at least two seasons if not three. While it is slow to wear, the tire is designed to offer optimal snow traction for only the first part of its life, dropping off noticeably once you’ve worn past its tire sipes. No “multi-cell” tubule technology or “bite particle” technology will have some questioning the purchase of this tire. But for those unwilling to compromise on dry-road handling, this may be the tire for you.

Toyo Observe Garit KX

Toyo Observe Garit KX

-A great performance winter tire that trades the Observe G-02’s tire squirm for sporty handling on dry roads. Of course, some traction on snow and ice is sacrificed, but considering the high level of tire squirm on the G-02s, this may be the better compromise for a mix of dry and snow covered road conditions. Tire wear is good, but falls behind others in-class such as the Michelin or Bridgestone mentioned above. The Garit KX contains Toyo’s walnut shell “bite particle” technology like its sibling, the Observe G-02 Plus.

For the best selection of wheels and tires, please visit TireRack (Disclaimer: Affiliate Link)

  • Ian

    no question about it. If it’s cold in winter where you live you need winter tires. They are now compulsory on quebec roads. If you get caught without them you get a fine. It’s a really good thing.

  • bmwm6

    Yea I am always on winter tires on my BMW
    my toyota gets all season and my chevy truck is Winter tires

  • bmwm6

    and I live in Canada

  • Brookside

    Anything over an 1″ of snow can bring my 3-er coupe to standstill with the oem Bridgestone runflats. And I’m an ex-Chicagoan….I grew up driving in the snow and slush.
    Solution- A set of winter tires and it’ll run through just about anything Mother Nature throws at me.

    A great article. Good point about the expense of towing and accidents vs. the cost of winter tires.

  • Horatiu Boe

    Great article Shawn!! I hope this one will serve as a reference in the future

  • Arthuro

    i have vredenstein tyres R19 and they are really good

    • NewJalf

      I have a second set of wheels that I’ll be fitting the Vredestein Wintrac 4 Extremes on to for next winter.

  • David Simon

    I’ve had Michelin Pilot Alpins for my 530i sport since purchased in ’07. Definitely a must. Despite the fact that BMW states quite clearly that the summer performance tires are for summer only and don’t perform well at temperatures around the freezing mark, it is amazing how many bimmers I see in winter still shod in OEM summer rubber in winter.

  • Richi

    Well, here in Germany, winter tires are not a real duty, but the law says that “…the owner has to adapt the car to the weather conditions….”.
    So at beginning of October when you recognize that the tepmerature at night is going down under the 7°C marking, it is better to have winter tires, because the gum of a summer tire looses contact to the ground.
    Another important thing is, that if you have an accident and the police examines the car and they recognise that you have summer tires in winter, the insurance will not pay the repair at your car and also not at the other car.
    So it’s better to have both summer and winter tires.

    • Horatiu B.

      You’re right when I picked up our first European Delivery car about 5 years ago, I was told I can’t drive on summer tires. I did, which wasn’t smart, but not for long distances so I was able to avoid a ticket.

  • Matt

    Thanks for the overview and recommendations. One of the better explanations I’ve seen. I’m probably going to lean towards the better dry traction options. Although Chicago gets some storms, it is mainly very cold and dry or slightly wet for most of the winter. We always seem to get hit while traveling on a holiday so they will be nice to have.

  • Redditch tyres

    Check the size and specification details for your tyres in your owner’s handbook. Write down the exact make and model names of your first- and second-choice cheap tyres.

  • winterbanden met velg

    Thx for sharing! We are a dutch blog about winter tyres and we confirm your findings about the extra safety winter tyres offer in the winter.

  • used cars

    In the case of wider tires, the added width also creates a larger point of contact between the tire and the road.

  • Rochus

    I do agree that it’s the safest and best choice to drive winter tires when the temperatures drop near freezing point. And I always drive winter tires through winters. But it is proven, that summer tires have better grip on dry and wet tarmac, regardless of the air and ground temperature. So your claims are wrong. You can find test results and researches on the internet. The only advantage of winter tires is on snow and ice. Huge advantage though. And there is another thing in your article, that I would like to emphasise. AWD cars provide almost double the grip transfered to the tarmac, so the difference between 2WD and 4WD/AWD cars on slippery roads is enormous. Even at cornering, because on the limit, all of your wheels provide traction and thus higher cornering speeds and better control of the vehicle in a case of a drift. It is true, that the AWD does not help at braking, because of the extra weight of the AWD system it sometimes makes the stopping distances even a bit longer. But not always. Braking with an AWD car on a slippery road with your engine (shifting down) and car without traction control (TC, ESP, ACS, DSC …) will prevent locking your wheels and unstabilising your vehicle beacuse the engine turns all four wheel and not just two, where the wheel lock can easily occur. Four tires provide much more grip than only two and by that the engine braking force has to be bigger to outpower the traction of the tires. The almost double traction amount makes the difference again.

    So the difference between summer and winter tires in winter conditions is huge and the difference between 2WD and AWD cars is also as big. But even AWD cars need winter tires on snow, to be on the safe side, no doubt about that.

    Trust me, I drive the best AWD and RWD cars. Subaru and BMW of course.