Would you choose a Cadillac CTS over a BMW M5?

BMW M5 | October 31st, 2008 by 32
audi s6 2009 1280x960 wallpaper 02 Would you choose a Cadillac CTS over a BMW M5?

This seems to be a popular question these days and I see more and more blogs or auto magazines talking about the CTS-V as being …

This seems to be a popular question these days and I see more and more blogs or auto magazines talking about the CTS-V as being a strong competitor for the BMW M5 or for the MB E63 and Audi S6.

Josh, our editor, made a nice comparison a while back that covered some interesting angles. For example, the Cadillac CTS-V has a 6.2L Supercharged V8, packing 556hp at 6100 RPM and 551lb-ft of torque at 3800 RPM. For such a large engine, the CTS-V only weighs 4200/4300lbs, in manual and automatic transmission.

On the other hand, BMW’s super sedan, the M5, is powered by a naturally aspirated V10 that has 500hp at 7750 RPM and 383lb-ft of torque at 6100 RPM. The M5 is a bit lighter than the CTS, weighing 4012 lbs.

073020081942149255 Would you choose a Cadillac CTS over a BMW M5?

For fun, let’s throw in there the Audi S6 as well. The S6 features an all aluminium alloy 5,204 cc Fuel Stratified Injection (FSI) 40-valve V10 petrol engine, derived from the Lamborghini Gallardo, re-tuned to produce 430 bhp at 6800 rpm and 400 ft·lbf of torque between 3000 – 4000 rpm. It utilises twin chain-driven double overhead camshafts (DOHC), and variable valve timing for both intake and exhaust valves. An impressive engine that delivers great performance. But all of this comes with a price: a total weight of 4,486 lbs.

Now before we go even further and you jumping all over me, I need to clarify one thing: YES, I know the S6 is not really the direct competitor to the aferomentioned super luxury sedans, but unfortunately, the more powerful and beautiful RS6 is not available in the U.S.

From a technical stand point, the Audi S6 seems to be the “little guy” in this game, but what if we focus a little bit now on the design aspect? Let me throw some photos at you and let you decide for yourself.

But before I end this short comparison, I would like to state my personal opinion. As much as I am bimmer fan, I was never 100% attracted to the overall design of an M5. But here is what I like:

  • big fan of Audi’s front-end
  • huge fan of the side stand an M5 has
  • the M5 rear turns me on
  • crazy about the Audi A6’s space ship interior
  • I totally dig the aggressive look of a CTS-V

So, which one would you choose, without being biased of course?

orig 09cts v009 498x331 Would you choose a Cadillac CTS over a BMW M5?

BMWBLOG

NEWSLETTER